51社区黑料

A new 51社区黑料 study has detailed police officers鈥� attitudes towards British Columbia鈥檚 pilot drug decriminalization policy.

Researchers interviewed 30 active-duty officers, who were responsible for implementing the policy on the streets of B.C.

The results indicate a disconnect between the policy鈥檚 broader public health objectives and the everyday experiences of police officers, according to lead researcher Amanda Butler.

鈥淯nderstanding the views of frontline police officers is really important if you want to determine how well the policy worked and what lessons can be taken forward,鈥� says Butler, an assistant professor in SFU鈥檚 School of Criminology.

鈥淲hile many of the officers had distinct reservations about the policy, it was really clear that they feel a deep concern about the harm and deaths they鈥檙e witnessing in their communities.

鈥淢any officers described a genuine commitment to reducing harm, particularly in the context of the drug toxicity crisis. At the same time, they expressed feeling limited in their ability to affect meaningful change.鈥�

The three-year drug decriminalization pilot launched in B.C. in January 2023 and came to an end earlier this year. It allowed people to be in possession of 2.5 grams of illicit drugs.

The policy鈥檚 aims included making it easier for people struggling with addiction to get the help they need by reducing stigma and increasing access to services.

Last week also marked 10 years since B.C. announced a public health emergency in response to an increase in toxic drug deaths.

Future lessons

Researchers conducted interviews with active police officers in different parts of B.C., including RCMP members and the province鈥檚 municipal police departments, between November 2023 and March 2024.

The findings, published in the , are grouped into four themes that emerged from the interviews:

• Criminal law reform
• Health resource cards
• Criminal justice system involvement
• Stigma reduction

鈥淭he officers overwhelmingly perceived a lack of coordinated investments and change in social and health services, and believed that without these the policy was unlikely to achieve its goals,鈥� says Butler.

鈥淓ngaging frontline providers and incorporating on-the-ground experience in policy design and implementation may strengthen future drug reform efforts.

鈥淚n addition, training for police officers should include education related to stigma, addiction and longer-term policy goals. This may help to foster buy-in and reduce the gap between policy intent and frontline realities.鈥�

Criminal law reform

Many officers emphasized the importance of robust health and social service systems in achieving the policy鈥檚 primary goal of reducing overdose deaths.

However, several participants expressed frustration at perceived shortcomings in this area. Some officers felt the policy was not evidence-based but politically-motivated and rushed.

Officers also felt increasingly burdened with health-related emergencies without new resources.

Officer comments:

鈥淭his is supposed to be a multipronged multifaceted approach. They haven't implemented any of the other things that they're supposed to do in order to support this vision or direction of these goals. It's not enough on its own just to decriminalize drugs. Unless they have the support mechanisms in place that they promised for people.鈥�

鈥淲hen you build a house, you start with the foundation鈥ecriminalization, that's the framing, right? That's the finishing touches, the details. They didn't build the foundation of the house. They didn't have the support services in place.鈥�

鈥淚t feels like a sinking boat and using a spoon to try to get the water out of a sinking boat.鈥�

Health resource cards

As part of the policy, officers were tasked with distributing health resource cards to drug users whenever there was a police interaction or when someone requested a service, program or treatment.

The health resource cards provided provincial resources such as 24/7 crisis lines, drug checking services, and a join code for receiving toxic drug alerts.

Officers almost unanimously viewed these cards as ineffective or symbolic, and in some cases, problematic. A key criticism was the generic nature and lack of local tailoring, and that resources are often inadequate or inaccessible.

Officer comments:

鈥淚鈥檝e seen people do it and they laugh at you, tear [the resource cards] up, throw [it] on the ground right away. Like that card is going to somehow help them? It鈥檚 a token gesture. That card is not going to do anything for anybody.鈥�

鈥淚 try to talk people into accepting help and resources. And I will never not do that... But this mandatory handing out of cards to people [that] tell me to 鈥榚ff鈥� off every time I offer it has not been received very well.鈥�

Criminal justice system

Although drug decriminalization is intended to reduce criminal penalties and the burden on the justice system, few officers viewed this as an immediate or central goal of B.C.鈥檚 policy.

Many were skeptical of its potential to meaningfully reduce criminal legal system involvement, citing long-standing discretionary policing practices that had already deprioritized personal drug possession.

Nearly all officers in the study reported that personal possession laws had not been actively enforced for several years.

Officers also discussed that some people who use drugs continue to be involved in offences indirectly linked to drug use, such as property crime and theft.

Officer comments:

鈥淚鈥檝e spoken to many drug users over 15 years鈥� I have never in my history of policing charged anybody for the simple possession of drugs.鈥�

鈥淎 lot of property crime and a lot of petty theft is to fuel their drug use鈥hey have an underlying addiction that they鈥檙e trying to maintain. And so, because they鈥檙e a drug user and they commit theft and steal from other people, are we now going to not charge them because they鈥檙e a drug user?鈥�

Stigma

Officers expressed a range of views around the policy goal of reducing stigma. Some officers believed destigmatization was important, but doubted the policy鈥檚 ability to achieve it.

Some officers believed that societal stigma had worsened since the policy was introduced.

While some officers felt that efforts to reduce stigma were important and worthwhile, others felt that drug use should be stigmatized as a deterrent.

Officer comments:

鈥淚 heard the goal of the policy was to try to destigmatize it [drugs] ... People would be more willing to get help and all this stuff. I haven鈥檛 really seen that.鈥�

鈥淚t鈥檚 [decriminalization] had the opposite effect鈥� I would say that it has driven more of the general public to have more of a stigma towards drug use than anything.鈥�

鈥淵ou don鈥檛 want to normalize using drugs. They have enormous mental health, physical, and societal negative impacts. To say that we should just accept it as just a choice and we should just be okay with people using fentanyl, it shouldn鈥檛 be. I don鈥檛 have anything negative to say about somebody using fentanyl, other than to say, 鈥榟ey鈥ou need to get help鈥欌� don鈥檛 support de-stigmatizing the use of hardcore drugs.鈥�

AVAILABLE EXPERT

AMANDA BUTLER, assistant professor, School of Criminology
albutler@sfu.ca

CONTACT

SAM SMITH, 51社区黑料Communication & Marketing
236.880.3297 | mediarelations@sfu.ca

Communications & Marketing鈥�触鈥�51社区黑料Media Experts Directory鈥�鈥赌�
778.782.3210鈥�

ABOUT SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY鈥赌�
Who We Are鈥�
51社区黑料is a leading research university, advancing an inclusive and sustainable future. Over the past 60 years, 51社区黑料has been recognized among the top universities worldwide in providing a world-class education and working with communities and partners to develop and share knowledge for deeper understanding and meaningful impact. Committed to excellence in everything we do, 51社区黑料fosters innovation to address global challenges and continues to build a welcoming, inclusive community where everyone feels a sense of belonging. With campuses in British Columbia鈥檚 three largest cities鈥擝urnaby,鈥疭urrey鈥痑nd Vancouver鈥�51社区黑料has ten faculties that deliver 368 undergraduate degree programs and 149 graduate degree programs for more than 37,000 students each year. The university boasts more than 200,000 alumni鈥痳esiding鈥痠n 145+ countries.鈥�